2009/03/09

The Law Lie - 3 - Customs


In the previous two posts in this series I tried to show some history of two parts of what I call “the Law Lie” (itself a part of what I call “the God Lie”), namely, 1) the lie that morality is defined by the gods and 2) the lie that justice is the jurisdiction of the gods. In this post I want to show a little history of a third part of the Law Lie: 3) the lie that customs were created by the gods. We can be extremely confident that the above (and the many other parts of the God Lie) aren’t valid descriptions of reality, simply because (as I’ve argued elsewhere) the firmest knowledge that we have – even firmer than the knowledge that we exist! – is that no god exists or has ever existed.

I admit, however, that there’s only circumstantial evidence that such “untruths” are also lies (rather than mistakes). This “circumstantial evidence” includes the existence of a huge number of clerical parasites who profit from promoting such silliness, even though ample evidence is readily available to demonstrate that the concepts are wrong. Nonetheless, most clerics may be fools rather than liars; that is, the liars may be only those few clerics who aren’t fools.

In any event, it’s easy to imagine how primitive people reached the mistaken conclusion that, for example, customs were created by the gods. Having convinced themselves that the gods were “the cause” of everything unknown (from the cause of the wind to the reason for the lights in the sky), then upon finding their societies in possession of a host of cultural peculiarities (from sharing food with others to prohibitions against eating certain foods, and from the existence of the concept of marriage to prohibitions against specific sexual activities), it was then logical to deduce (based on the faulty premiss that gods exist) that the gods created their society’s customs.

Now, to investigate the real origins of all customs of any particular society would be an absolutely humongous task; therefore, I plan to severely restrict this post. My goal is to provide some evidence for the origins of only a few of the customs that the authors and “redactors” of the Old Testament (OT) claimed were given to them by their god. The few customs on which I plan to focus are, however, arguably the most important, namely, the customs revealed in “the wisdom literature” of the OT’s Proverbs.

By restricting the scope of this post to customs depicted in the OT’s Proverbs I’m not suggesting my disinterest in origins of other facets of Ancient Hebrew culture. Elsewhere, I’ve already commented (at least a little) on their male chauvinism, which (by the way) is still practiced by most Muslims and which seems to have been derived as a part of the cultural transition from rural to urban life, with associated shift in emphasis from fertility (and female fertility goddesses) to trade and intercity warfare (and associated male gods). Also, in a later post, I plan at least to glance at how the Hebrews apparently combined Egyptian, Persian, and Greek ideas about the gods to (erroneously) conclude that there was only a single god.

Readers interested in other peculiarities of Hebrew culture, such as their aversion to pork and their brutal practice of male circumcision, might want to start by reading The History by Herodotus (who reports in Paragraphs 2.36, 2.37, and 2.47 that both customs were earlier practiced in Ancient Egypt) and then explore further on the internet to find, for example, that the first historical record of male circumcision is associated with the Egyptian physician Ankhmahor (c. 2300 BCE). Originally, the practice of male circumcision seems to have been a part of any boy’s “coming of age” initiation rite, starting in Africa tens of thousands of years ago and spreading worldwide with the aborigines of Australia and South America.

In defense of my plan to focus on Hebrew customs revealed in the OT’s Proverbs, I would not only point to the need to restrict the length of the post but also claim that a substantial portion of the customs of any culture is revealed by its “wisdom literature.” For what follows, my plan is first to display the wisdom literature of earlier, Sumerian and Egyptian cultures, then display some of the Hebrew wisdom literature as given in the OT’s Proverbs, and then, finally, ask the reader to consider clerical claims that the wisdom of the Hebrews was derived not from the people’s experiences but from the first symmetry-breaking fluctuation in the total void that led to the Big Bang (i.e., from “God”).

The first clear record of existing customs appeared when writing was invented, about 5,000 years ago in Sumer, in what’s now called southern Iraq (“Sumer” means “from the south”). Examples of Sumerian customs are contained in their many proverbs available at the Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature. In that source, I found particularly informative the following proverbs, which I’ve grouped under the indicated headings. Question marks (?) indicate translation uncertainties and (. . .) indicates missing text. Although it’s unknown when these proverbs were developed, they’re obviously from a time period at least twice as long ago as the time period when the OT was put together.

General Sumerian Customs
A good word is a friend to numerous men.

You speak to me – and I will speak to you!

He who insults is insulted. He who sneers is sneered at.

Putting unwashed hands to one’s mouth is disgusting.

One city does not greet another, but one person greets another person.

A hand will stretch out towards an outstretched hand. A hand will open for an opened hand.
Sumerian Family Life
“I’m going home” is what he prefers.

Marry a wife according to your choice. Have children to your heart’s content.

He who does not support a wife, he who does not support a child, has no cause for celebration.

Children and wives and trading agents! How they use up silver! And how they use up barley!

To be sick is acceptable; to be pregnant is painful; but to be pregnant and sick is just too much.

Hand added to hand, and a man’s house is built up. Stomach (?) added to stomach (?), and a man’s house is destroyed.

A malicious wife living in a house is the worst of all afflictions.

When I married a malicious husband, when I bore a malicious son, an unhappy heart was assigned to me.

I will feed you even though you are an outcast (?). I will give you drink even though you are an outcast (?). You are still my son, even if your god has turned against you.

A brewing (?) trough not previously tried is put to the test by means of salt. A mixing jar (?) not previously tried is put to the test by means of water. A son-in-law whose behavior (?) is unknown is put to the test by means of quarrels.

A man’s waterskin is his life. A man’s sandals are his eyes. A man’s wife is his supervisor (?). A man’s son is his protective shade. A man’s daughter is his eager servant (?). A man’s daughter-in-law is his policeman.

The joy of a daughter-in-law is anger.

As for the fiancé, what has he brought? And as for the father-in-law, what has he sorted out?

For his pleasure he got married. On his thinking it over he got divorced.

The married man, having divorced his wife, examined her: “At least I am taking away my dignity!”

An unfaithful penis matches (?) an unfaithful vagina.

No one walks together with him or directs their steps towards him. Life {passes him by like water} {(1 ms. has instead:) eludes him just as he avoids others}. He is dear to no just man, {plague prevails over him} {(1 ms. has instead:) life is not given to him}. Like a worthless penny, {......; no one ......} {(1 ms. has instead:) he is thrown away; no one cares about him}. He is clothed with a garment as if a heavy punishment were assigned to him. {Who is he? His name? A man sleeping with someone’s wife.} {(1 ms. has instead:) Who is he? He is a man who slept with someone’s wife.}
Sumerian Work & Professional Life
While you still have light, grind the flour.

The warrior is unique; he alone is the equal of many.

The axe belongs to the carpenter, the stone belongs to the smith, the good ...... belongs to the brewer.

He who has silver is happy. He who has grain feels comfortable. But he who has livestock cannot sleep.

He who has silver, he who has lapis lazuli, he who has oxen, and he who has sheep wait at the gate of the man who has barley.

He who shaves his head gets more hair. And he who gathers the barley gains more and more grain.

It is on account of being the boss that you bully me.

If the foreman does not know how to assign the work, his workers will not stop shaking their heads.

How will a scribe who does not know Sumerian produce a translation?

The idleness of a low-life causes losses; his shying away (?) from work is perpetual.

Although you poured out water from a river of mighty waters, it did not cool my temper. It did not put an end (?) to the sorcery affecting me.

When battle approaches, when war arises, the plans of the gods, beloved by the gods, are destroyed. You cause fire to devour the Land. May my god know that my hand is suited to the stylus.

A disgraced scribe becomes an incantation priest. A disgraced singer becomes a flute-player. A disgraced lamentation priest becomes a piper. A disgraced merchant becomes a con-man. A disgraced carpenter becomes a man of the spindle. A disgraced smith becomes a man of the sickle. A disgraced mason becomes a hod-carrier.

“You should serve me” is typical of purification priests. Bowing over your hips is typical of leather-workers. To be stationed in all corners is typical of lukur women [“sacred prostitutes”]. “I will be there with you” is typical of gardeners. “I swear by Enki that your garments will take no time in this establishment” is typical of fullers.
General Sumerian Wisdom
The fool is garrulous.

Flies enter an open mouth.

He turns things upside down.

Your role in life is unknown.

Not to know beer is not normal.

The time passed, and what did you gain?

The stupidest of all shameless men.

In the city with no dogs, the fox is boss.

In the city of the lame, the cripple is a courier.

The mighty man is master of the earth.

A palace will fall of its own accord.

Strength cannot keep pace with intelligence.

Who could compete with righteousness?

Good is in the hands. Evil is also in the hands.

A millstone will float in the river for a righteous man.

When righteousness is cut off, injustice is increased.

The expenses (?) of those who neglect justice are numerous.

Let just men be born in good health, and let their lives last long.

The just man’s life lasts long. Life is the gift awarded for it.

What comes out of one’s mouth is not in one’s hand.

Tell a lie and then tell the truth: it will be considered a lie.

As long as you live you should not increase evil by telling lies; for if you do, to succumb will be your lot.

Talking endlessly is what humankind has most on its mind.

Whatever the man in authority said, it was not pleasant.

The poor man inflicts all kinds of illnesses on the rich man.

That which the thief has taken was made by an honest man.

The beloved true commander distributes the leadership (?).

Let great men stir up the conflict for lesser men to fight out.

Is my ox to provide milk for you?

Moving about defeats poverty.

A stranger is leader in a foreign city.

Like an ox, you do not know how to turn back.

He who keeps fleeing, flees from his own past.

Because he always went, because he always ran, “He carried away. He carried away!” is the name assigned to him. A fool.

A fettered dog is quarrelsome.

When a dog snarls, throw a morsel into his mouth.

Don’t start a fight with a dog. Will that dog not bite you?

“Like the wild bull, you only do what pleases you.”

He who says “I will live for today” is bound like a bull on a nose-rope.

A fox urinated into the Tigris. “I am causing the spring flood to rise,” he said.

Brotherhood is founded on the words of a quarrel. At the witness box, friendship becomes known.

Although I spoke, what did I gain? Although I spoke, what did it add? I covered up for myself, but what success did it bring me?

What is in mankind’s mouth is as difficult to hide as a wall. The boy who grew up in your town ...... on you – don’t let your mouth accuse him; don’t slander him; don’t encourage violent retaliation against yourself.

One should pay attention to an old man’s words and one should reap the benefits.

By following craftiness, one learns how to be crafty. By following wisdom, one learns how to be wise.

A child should behave with modesty toward his mother. He should take the older generation into consideration.

A younger brother should honor an older brother. He should treat him with human dignity.

Should not intelligence, wisdom and understanding become perfect ...... to the mouth ...... mankind.

Let the favor be repaid to him who repays a favor.

He who can say “Let him hurry, let him run, let him be strong, and he will carry it!” is a lucky man.

When present, it was considered a loincloth; when lost, it is considered fine clothing.

To eat modestly doesn’t kill a man, but to covet will murder you. To eat a little is to live splendidly. When you walk about, keep your feet on the ground!

The ditches of the garden should not flow with water, or there will be vermin.

Don’t cause the oven in a man’s house to smoke. The smoke will ruin (?) the bread.

Because of his arrogance, may his head be bowed to his neck like a damp reed.

He who possesses many things is constantly on his guard.

A wealthy man had accumulated a fortune. “I am spending it for him.” That said, it was dispersed. Afterwards he could not work out what went wrong. Things change. No one knows what will happen.

My fingernail that hurts is clutched in my embrace. My foot that hurts is in my sandal. But who will find my aching heart?

Let me tell you about my fate: it is a disgrace. Let me tell you of my condition: it makes a man’s mouth taste bitter.

A child without sin was never born by his mother. The idea was never conceived that there was anyone who was not a sinner. Such a situation never existed.

Although the number of unhappy days is endless (?), yet life is better than death.

Pleasure is created. Sins are absolved. Life is rejuvenated.
Notice that none of the above Sumerian proverbs emphasized the gods; in contrast, those listed below emphasize the gods indicated by the headings. For further information on the Sumerian gods see here.

General Gods
… the gods are three. So it is said, so let it be.

A man without a god – for a strong man it is no loss.

To appreciate the earth is for the gods; I am merely covered in dust.

What has been destroyed belongs to a god. No one is able to take it away.

To be wealthy and demand more is an abomination to a god.

Accept your lot and make your mother happy! Run fast and make your god happy!

Should someone clever not act cleverly, then I ......; man’s intelligence comes from god.

Thanks to the word of his personal god, the fate of the man who speaks just words is favorable, and he is with him throughout the day.

A man without a personal god does not procure much food, does not procure even a little food. Going down to the river, he does not catch any fish. Going down to a field, he does not catch any gazelle. In important matters he is unsuccessful. When running, he does not reach his goal. Yet were his god favorable toward him, anything he might name would be provided for him.
The god Utu (Shamash in Akkadian), the Sun god and god of justice
If wickedness exerts itself, how will Utu succeed?

Whenever wickedness may cause trouble, Utu will not be idle!

Uncleared debts ...... are something which makes debts to Utu.

When a trustworthy boat is sailing, Utu seeks out a trustworthy harbor for it.

Adding an inheritance share to an inheritance share is an abomination to Utu.

The palace is an ox; you should catch it by the tail. Utu is lord; you should fix your gaze on him.

He who despises a just decision, who loves wicked decisions, is an abomination to Utu.

Utu, the lord who loves justice, extirpates wickedness and prolongs righteousness.

Utu’s glance is prayerful. Utu’s heart is compassionate. A devotee of Utu is among the holy. Allotted by Utu to be fortunate, a ...... ship reaches the quay.

When a man comes forward as a witness, saying: “Let me tell you what I know,” but does not know the relevant information, it is an abomination to Utu.

A judge who despises justice, cursing with the right hand, and the chasing away of a younger son from the house of his father are abominations to Utu.

Oh Utu, you are my judge: pronounce my judgment! You are my decision-maker, decide my case! The dream that I have seen – turn it into a favorable one!

To spit without covering it up with dust and to use the tongue at midday without protection are abominations to Utu.

To serve beer with unwashed hands, to spit without trampling upon it, to sneeze without covering it with dust, to kiss with the tongue at midday without providing shade are abominations to Utu.

The wolf wept before Utu: “The animals frisk around together, but I am all alone.”

Imagine a wolf is eating. Utu looks down on it and says: “Provided you praise me you will grow fat” would be the reply.

While the wolf sat stuck in a trap, he said to Utu: “When I come out, let me henceforth eat no more sheep. When I am hungry, the sheep I’ve taken, whatever you mention – what will they mean to me? I shall be bound by a righteous oath. – Now, what can I eat?”
Enlil, the god of the Earth, wind, and storms (one of the three great gods, the others two being the sky god Anu and the water god Enki or Ea)
The fox lies (?) even to Enlil.

Enlil’s greatest punishment is hunger.

… you shouldn’t give a lame man a staff. Enlil is his helper.

Don’t give the halt man a club for his arm. Enlil shall be the one to help him!

A fox demanded of Enlil the horns of a wild bull. While it was wearing the wild bull’s horns, it started to rain. But the horns rose high above him, so he could not enter his burrow. Until midnight the wind kept blowing, and the clouds brought rain. Afterwards, when it had stopped raining on him, and he had dried off, he said: “I shall return this feature to its rightful owner!”
Suen, the Moon god and god of wisdom (called Nanna or Sin in Akkadian)
… if the hand touches a woman’s genitals over her clothes – it is an abomination to Suen.

When a man sailing downstream encounters a man whose boat is traveling upstream, an inspection is an abomination to Suen.

When a man comes forward as a witness, saying: “Let me tell you what I know about him”, but does not know the relevant information, it is an abomination to Suen.

The north wind is a satisfying wind; the south wind is harmful (?) to man. The east wind is a rain-bearing wind; the west wind is greater than those who live there. The east wind is a wind of prosperity, the friend of Naram-Suen.
Inana (Akkadian, Ishtar), goddess of fertility, represented by Venus
May Inana pour oil on my heart that aches.

For him who is rejected by Inana, his dream is to forget.

Carrying bread to the oven whilst singing is an abomination to Inana.

May Inana make a hot-limbed wife lie with you! May she bestow upon you broad-shouldered sons! May she find for you a place of happiness!
Ninurta, healing god and god of the South Wind
To take revenge is the prerogative of Ninurta.

To take revenge is an abomination to Ninurta.

Refusing to talk is an abomination to Ninurta.

To remove something from its proper place is an abomination to Ninurta.

They treated an immigrant badly. [1 line fragmentary] It is an abomination to Ninurta.

Coveting and {reaching out for things} {(1 ms. has instead:) spying} are abominations to Ninurta.

The chasing away of a younger son from the house of his father is an abomination to Ninurta.

A judge who despises justice, cursing with the right hand, and the chasing away of a younger son from the house of his father are abominations to Ninurta.
Other Gods
I part the waters (?) like Nirah [a snake deity].

You should not say to Ninjizzida [god of nature]: “Let me live!”

When the authorities are wise, and the poor are loyal, it is the effect of the blessing of Aratta [the land].

He who slanders… for the liar – Ninegala [Ningal (?), the Moon goddess?] will crush his head…

A plant as sweet as a husband, a plant as sweet as a mother; may Ezina-Kusu (the grain goddess) dwell in your home.

The god of the river ordeal will admire the hearts of those who bear words of truth.
Similar sayings were undoubtedly available in Ancient Egypt (and other regions), but most Egyptian writings were recorded on papyrus, which (of course) was much more perishable than clay tablets. Some Egyptian sayings were also carved in stone (e.g., on tombs and in pyramids), but of course, such carvings emphasized the “afterlife” of the dead person. Some of the tomb inscriptions, however, provide at least a glimpse of early Egyptian customs – at least, those customs followed (or claimed to be followed!) by the aristocrats buried in the tombs. An example of a tomb inscription that does convey some ideas about Ancient Egyptian culture is the following.
Inscriptions of Harkhuf, The Explorer (~2525 BCE)
I came today from my city, I descended from my nome, I built a house, I set up the doors. I dug a lake, and I planted trees. The King praised me. My father made a will for me, for I was excellent . . . one beloved of his father, praised of his mother, whom all his brothers loved. I gave bread to the hungry, clothing to the naked, I ferried him who had no boat.

I was one saying good things and repeating what was loved. Never did I say aught evil, to a powerful one against any people, for I desired that it might be well with me in the great god’s presence. Never did I judge two brothers in such a way that a son was deprived of his paternal possession.
A much more significant indication of Ancient Egyptian culture is available on “the world’s most precious and oldest papyrus known”, namely, the Prisse Papyrus (named after the Frenchmen who purchased it). It contains The Precepts [or The Maxims of Good Discourse] of Ptah-Hotep.

Actually, the identity of the author isn’t known. There was a vizier under King Isesi called Ptah-Hotep (or Ptahhotep, which seems to mean Ptah is “at peace” or “is satisfied”, where Ptah was claimed by the clerics of Memphis to be the creator god). If this Ptah-Hotep was the author of The Precepts, then they are from 2450–2300 BCE. On the other hand, The Precepts may be a “literary construct”, as apparently were other Instructions of fathers to their sons; if so, then The Precepts may be from ~2300–2150 BCE and by an unknown author. In any case, the author probably relied on available Egyptian proverbs, possibly including those from the time of the first recognized genius in history, the “first engineer, architect, and physician”, Imhotep, c. 2600 BCE.

The full text of The Precepts is available at many places on the web, including here, here, and at The Internet Ancient History Source Book. What follows is an abbreviated form of the text copied from here. I’ve taken the liberty to italicize portions of the text that I found to be particularly perceptive.
Precepts of the Prefect, the lord Ptah-hotep, under the Majesty of the King of the South and North, Assa, living eternally forever.

Beginning of the arrangement of the good sayings, spoken by the noble lord, the divine father, beloved of Ptah, the son of the king, the first-born of his race, the prefect and feudal lord Ptah-hotep, so as to instruct the ignorant in the knowledge of the arguments of the good sayings. It is profitable for him who hears them; it is a loss to him who shall transgress them. He says to his son:

Be not arrogant because of that which you know; deal with the ignorant as with the learned; for the barriers of art are not closed, no artist being in possession of the perfection to which he should aspire. But good words are more difficult to find than the emerald, for it is by slaves that that is discovered among the rocks of pegmatite…

If you find a disputant while he is hot, do not despise him because you are not of the same opinion. Be not angry against him when he is wrong; away with such a thing. He fights against himself; require him not further to flatter your feelings. Do not amuse yourself with the spectacle which you have before you; it is odious, it is mean, it is the part of a despicable soul so to do. As soon as you let yourself be moved by your feelings, combat this desire as a thing that is reproved by the great…

If you have, as leader, to decide on the conduct of a great number of men, seek the most perfect manner of doing so that your own conduct may be without reproach. Justice is great, invariable, and assured; it has not been disturbed since the age of Ptah. To throw obstacles in the way of the laws is to open the way before violence…

Inspire not men with fear, else Ptah will fight against you in the same manner. If any one asserts that he lives by such means, Ptah will take away the bread from his mouth; if any one asserts that he enriches himself thereby, Ptah says: I may take those riches to myself. If any one asserts that he beats others, Ptah will end by reducing him to impotence. Let no one inspire men with fear; this is the will of Ptah. Let one provide sustenance for them in the lap of peace; it will then be that they will freely give what has been torn from them by terror…

If you are a farmer, gather the crops in the field which the great Ptah has given you, do not boast in the house of your neighbors; it is better to make oneself dreaded by one’s deeds. As for him who, master of his own way of acting, being all-powerful, seizes the goods of others like a crocodile in the midst even of watchment, his children are an object of malediction, of scorn, and of hatred on account of it, while his father is grievously distressed, and as for the mother who has borne him, happy is another rather than herself. But a man becomes a god when he is chief of a tribe which has confidence in following him…

Be active during the time of your existence; do no more than is commanded. Do not spoil the time of your activity; he is a blameworthy person who makes a bad use of his moments. Do not lose the daily opportunity of increasing that which your house possesses. Activity produces riches, and riches do not endure when it slackens…

He is a god who penetrates into a place where no relaxation of the rules is made for the privileged…

If you are a leader, setting forward your plans according to that which you decide, perform perfect actions which posterity may remember, without letting the words prevail with you which multiply flattery, which excite pride and produce vanity.

If you are a leader of peace, listen to the discourse of the petitioner. Be not abrupt with him; that would trouble him. Say not to him: “You have already recounted this.” Indulgence will encourage him to accomplish the object of his coming. As for being abrupt with the complainant because he described what passed when the injury was done, instead of complaining of the injury itself let it not be! The way to obtain a clear explanation is to listen with kindness.

If you desire to excite respect within the house you enter, for example the house of a superior, a friend, or any person of consideration, in short everywhere where you enter, keep yourself from making advances to a woman, for there is nothing good in so doing…

If you desire that your conduct should be good and preserved from all evil, keep yourself from every attack of bad humor. It is a fatal malady which leads to discord, and there is no longer any existence for him who gives way to it. For it introduces discord between fathers and mothers, as well as between brothers and sisters; it causes the wife and the husband to hate each other; it contains all kinds of wickedness, it embodies all kinds of wrong. When a man has established his just equilibrium and walks in this path, there where he makes his dwelling, there is no room for bad humor.

Be not of an irritable temper as regards that which happens at your side; grumble not over your own affairs. Be not of an irritable temper in regard to your neighbors; better is a compliment to that which displeases than rudeness. It is wrong to get into a passion with one’s neighbors, to be no longer master of one’s words. When there is only a little irritation, one creates for oneself an affliction for the time when one will again be cool.

If you are wise, look after your house; love your wife without alloy. Fill her stomach, clothe her back; these are the cares to be bestowed on her person. Caress her, fulfill her desires during the time of her existence; it is a kindness which does honor to its possessor. Be not brutal; tact will influence her better than violence; her . . . behold to what she aspires, at what she aims, what she regards. It is that which fixes her in your house; if you repel her, it is an abyss. Open your arms for her, respond to her arms; call her, display to her your love.

Treat your dependents well, in so far as it belongs to you to do so; and it belongs to those whom Ptah has favored…

Do not repeat any extravagance of language; do not listen to it; it is a thing which has escaped from a hasty mouth. If it is repeated, look, without hearing it, toward the earth; say nothing in regard to it. Cause him who speaks to you to know what is just, even him who provokes to injustice; cause that which is just to be done, cause it to triumph. As for that which is hateful according to the law, condemn it by unveiling it.

If you are a wise man, sitting in the council of your lord, direct your thought toward that which is wise. Be silent rather than scatter your words…

If you are powerful, respect knowledge and calmness of language. Command only to direct; to be absolute is to run into evil. Let not your heart be haughty, neither let it be mean. Do not let your orders remain unsaid and cause your answers to penetrate; but speak without heat, assume a serious countenance. As for the vivacity of an ardent heart, temper it; the gentle man penetrates all obstacles. He who agitates himself all the day long has not a good moment; and he who amuses himself all the day long keeps not his fortune…

Disturb not a great man; weaken not the attention of him who is occupied. His care is to embrace his task, and he strips his person through the love which he puts into it. That transports men to Ptah, even the love for the work which they accomplish. Compose then your face even in trouble, that peace may be with you, when agitation is with . . .These are the people who succeed in what they desire.

Let your love pass into the heart of those who love you; cause those about you to be loving and obedient…

If you are annoyed at a thing, if you are tormented by someone who is acting within his right, get out of his sight, and remember him no more when he has ceased to address you.

If you have become great after having been little, if you have become rich after having been poor, when you are at the head of the city, know how not to take advantage of the fact that you have reached the first rank, harden not your heart because of your elevation; you are become only the administrator, the prefect, of the provisions which belong to Ptah. Put not behind you the neighbor who is like you; be unto him as a companion…

Do not plunder the house of your neighbors; seize not by force the goods which are beside you…

If you aim at polished manners, call not him whom you accost. Converse with him especially in such a way as not to annoy him. Enter on a discussion with him only after having left him time to saturate his mind with the subject of the conversation. If he lets his ignorance display itself, and if he gives you all opportunity to disgrace him, treat him with courtesy rather; proceed not to drive him into a corner; do not . . . the word to him; answer not in a crushing manner; crush him not; worry him not; in order that in his turn he may not return to the subject, but depart to the profit of your conversation.

Let your countenance be cheerful during the time of your existence…

Know those who are faithful to you when you are in low estate…

If you take a wife, do not . . . Let her be more contented than any of her fellow-citizens. She will be attached to you doubly, if her chain is pleasant. Do not repel her; grant that which pleases her; it is to her contentment that she appreciates your work…

When a son receives the instruction of his father there is no error in all his plans. Train your son to be a teachable man whose wisdom is agreeable to the great. Let him direct his mouth according to that which has been said to him; in the docility of a son is discovered his wisdom. His conduct is perfect while error carries away the unteachable. Tomorrow knowledge will support him, while the ignorant will be destroyed.

As for the man without experience who listens not, he effects nothing whatsoever. He sees knowledge in ignorance, profit in loss; he commits all kinds of error, always accordingly choosing the contrary of what is praiseworthy. He lives on that which is mortal, in this fashion. His food is evil words, whereat he is filled with astonishment. That which the great know to be mortal he lives upon every day, flying from that which would be profitable to him, because of the multitude of errors which present themselves before him every day.

A son who attends is like a follower of Horus; he is happy after having attended. He becomes great, he arrives at dignity, he gives the same lesson to his children…

Let your thoughts be abundant, but let your mouth be under restraint…
Another important, surviving Egyptian papyrus contains The Instructions of Amenemope. It was written in the eleventh century BCE, mostly in the standard “negative declarations” of the time. The text states that it was “Written by the superintendent of the land, experienced in his office; the offspring of a scribe of the Beloved Land, the superintendent of produce, who fixes the grain measure, who sets the grain tax amount for his lord… Amenemope, the son of Danakht… for his son… [who is also] the son of the… chief singer of Horus, the Lady Tawosret.” Some of the text follows; again I’ve added the italics to emphasize ideas that impressed me.
Chapter 1: Give your years and hear what is said, give your mind over to their interpretation… If you spend a lifetime with these things in your heart, you will find it good fortune; you will discover my words to be a treasure house of life, and your body will flourish upon earth.

Chapter 2: Beware of stealing from a miserable man and of raging against the cripple… Don’t let yourself be involved in a fraudulent business, nor desire the carrying out of it… Something else of value in the heart of God is to stop and think before speaking.

Chapter 3: Do not get into a quarrel with the argumentative man nor incite him with words; proceed cautiously before an opponent, and give way to an adversary; sleep on it before speaking, for a storm come forth like fire in hay is the hot-headed man in his appointed time. May you be restrained before him; leave him to himself, and God will know how to answer him.

Chapter 4: The truly temperate man sets himself apart…

Chapter 5: Do not take by violence the shares of the temple, do not be grasping, and you will find overabundance… 
Do not say today is the same as tomorrow, or how will matters come to pass? When tomorrow comes, today is past… Fill yourself with silence, you will find life, and your body shall flourish upon earth.

Chapter 6: Do not displace the surveyor’s marker on the boundaries of the arable land, nor alter the position of the measuring line; do not be greedy for a plot of land, nor overturn the boundaries of a widow… As for the road in the field worn down by time, he who takes it violently for fields, if he traps by deceptive attestations, will be lassoed by the might of the moon… Take care not to topple over the boundary marks of the arable land, not fearing that you will be brought to court; man propitiates God by the might of the Lord when he sets straight the boundaries of the arable land… Desire, then, to make yourself prosper, and take care for the Lord of all; do not trample on the furrow of someone else; their good order will be profitable for you… So plough the fields, and you will find whatever you need, and receive the bread from your own threshing floor: better is the bushel which God gives you than five thousand deceitfully gotten, they do not spend a day in the storehouse or warehouse, they are no use for dough for beer, their stay in the granary is short-lived, when morning comes they will be swept away. Better, then, is poverty in the hand of God than riches in the storehouse; better is bread when the mind is at ease than riches with anxiety.

Chapter 7: Do not set your heart upon seeking riches, for there is no one who can ignore Destiny and Fortune. Do not set your thoughts on external matters: 
 for every man there is his appointed time… Do not exert yourself to seek out excess and your wealth will prosper for you; if riches come to you by theft, they will not spend the night with you; as soon as day breaks they will not be in your household… Do not be pleased with yourself (because of) riches acquired through robbery, neither complain about poverty…

Chapter 8: Set your good deeds throughout the world that you may greet everyone… Keep your tongue safe from words of detraction, and you will be the loved one of the people… set a good report on your tongue, while the bad thing is covered up inside you.

Chapter 9: Do not fraternize with the hot-tempered man, nor approach him to converse… take care of speaking thoughtlessly; when a man’s heart is upset, words travel faster than wind and rain.

Chapter 10: Do not address your intemperate friend in your unrighteousness, nor destroy your own mind; do not say to him, “May you be praised,” not meaning it, when there is fear within you. 
Do not converse falsely with a man, for it is the abomination of God. Do not separate your mind from your tongue; all your plans will succeed. You will be important before others, while you will be secure in the hand of God. God hates one who falsified words, his great abomination is duplicity.

Chapter 11: Do not covet the property of the dependent nor hunger for his bread…


Chapter 12: Do not covet the property of an official, and do not fill (your) mouth with too much food extravagantly… Do not deal with the intemperate man, nor associate yourself to a disloyal party.

Chapter 13: Do not lead a man astray reed pen or papyrus document: it is the abomination of God. Do not witness a false statement… Better it is to be praised as one loved by men than wealth in the storehouse; better is bread when the mind is at ease than riches with troubles.

Chapter 14: Do not pay attention to a person, nor exert yourself to seek out his hand, if he says to you, “take a bribe”… another time he will be brought (to judgment).

Chapter 15: Do well, and you will attain influence…

Chapter 16: Do not unbalance the scale nor make the weights false, nor diminish the fractions of the grain measure… Do not get for yourself short weights… If you see someone cheating, at a distance you must pass him by. Do not be avaricious for copper, and abjure fine clothes. What good is one cloaked in fine linen woven as med, when he cheats before God?…

Chapter 17: Beware of robbing the grain measure to falsify its fractions; do not act wrongfully through force…

Chapter 18: Do not go to bed fearing tomorrow, for when day breaks what is tomorrow? Man knows not what tomorrow is! God is success; Man is failure… Do not say, “I am without fault,” nor try to seek out trouble… Be strong in your heart, make your mind firm…

Chapter 19: Do not enter the council chamber in the presence of a magistrate and then falsify your speech… Tell the truth before the magistrate, lest he gain power over your body…

Chapter 20: Do not corrupt the people of the law court, nor put aside the just man; do not agree because of garments of white, nor accept one in rags. Take not the gift of the strong man, nor repress the weak for him. Justice is a wonderful gift of God, and He will render it to whomever he wishes… Do not falsify the oracles on a papyrus and (thereby) alter the designs of God. Do not arrogate to yourself the might of God as if Destiny and Fortune did not exist… Hand property over to its (rightful) owners, and seek out life for yourself…

Chapter 21: Do not say, I have found a strong protector and now I can challenge a man in my town. Do not say, I have found an active intercessor, and now I can challenge him whom I hate. Indeed, you cannot know the plans of God; you cannot perceive tomorrow… Empty not your soul to everybody, and do not diminish thereby your importance; do not circulate your words to others, nor fraternize with one who is too candid. Better is a man whose knowledge is inside him than one who talks to disadvantage…

Chapter 22: Do not castigate your companion in a dispute, and do not him say his innermost thoughts… May you first comprehend his accusation and cool down your opponent…

Chapter 23: Do not eat a meal in the presence of a magistrate, nor set to speaking first. 
If you are satisfied with false words, enjoy yourself with your spittle. Look at the cup in front of you, and let it suffice your need…

Chapter 24: Do not listen to the accusation of an official indoors, and then repeat it to another outside. 
Do not allow your discussions to be brought outside, so that your heart will not be grieved…

Chapter 25: Do not jeer at a blind man nor tease a dwarf, neither interfere with the condition of a cripple…

Chapter 26: Do not stay in the tavern and join someone greater than you, whether he be high or low in his station, an old man or a youth; but take as a friend for yourself someone compatible… When you see someone greater than you outside, and attendants following him, respect (him). 
And give a hand to an old man filled with beer: respect him as his children would. The strong arm is not weakened when it is uncovered, the back is not broken when one bends it; better is the poor man who speaks sweet words than the rich man who speaks harshly.

Chapter 27: Do not reproach someone older than you, for he has seen the Sun before you; do not let yourself be reported to the Aten when he rises, with the words, “Another young man has reproached an elder”…

Chapter 28: Do not expose a widow if you have caught her in the fields, nor fail to give way if she is accused. 
Do not turn a stranger away your oil jar that it may be made double for your family. 
God loves him who cares for the poor, more than him who respects the wealthy.

Chapter 29: Do not turn people away from crossing the river when you have room in your ferryboat…

Chapter 30: Mark for your self these thirty chapters: they please, they instruct, they are the foremost of all books; they teach the ignorant. 
If they are read to an ignorant man, he will be purified through them…
Now, consider the OT’s Proverbs. Below, I’ve arranged a number of them in three groups, in an attempt to illustrate that: 1) Similar to the claims made one to two thousand years earlier by the Sumerians and Egyptians, the Jewish clerics claimed that their customs came from their god, 2) Some of the proverbs certainly contain wisdom (reflecting the best customs of the Jews), and 3) Some of the proverbs are quite unwise. I’ve copied these proverbs from the digitized NET version of the Bible and added a few notes in brackets (especially to explain my reasons for claiming that some of the proverbs are unwise).

I. The claim in the OT’s Proverbs that God is the source:
2.6 For the Lord gives wisdom, and from his mouth comes knowledge and understanding.

6:16 There are six things that the Lord hates, even seven things that are an abomination to him: haughty eyes, a lying tongue, and hands that shed innocent blood, a heart that devises wicked plans, feet that are swift to run to evil, a false witness who pours out lies, and a person who spreads discord among family members.

8:22 The Lord created me [Wisdom] as the beginning of his works, before his deeds of long ago. From eternity I was appointed, from the beginning, from before the world existed.

11:1 The Lord abhors dishonest scales, but an accurate weight is his delight.

12:2 A good person obtains favor from the Lord, but the Lord condemns a person with wicked schemes.

14:31 The one who oppresses the poor insults his Creator, but whoever shows favor to the needy honors him.

15:9 The Lord abhors the way of the wicked, but he loves those who pursue righteousness.

16:33 The dice are thrown into the lap, but their every decision is from the Lord.

17:15 The one who acquits the guilty and the one who condemns the innocent – both of them are an abomination to the Lord.

18:22 The one who finds a wife finds what is enjoyable, and receives a pleasurable gift from the Lord.

19:14 A house and wealth are inherited from parents, but a prudent wife is from the Lord.

20:12 The ear that hears and the eye that sees – the Lord has made them both.
II. Some wise sayings in the OT’s Proverbs:
1:10 My child, if sinners try to entice you, do not consent!

1:32 For the waywardness of the simpletons will kill them, and the careless ease of fools will destroy them.

3:27 Do not withhold good from those who need it, when you have the ability to help. Do not say to your neighbor, “Go! Return tomorrow and I will give it,” when you have it with you at the time. Do not plot evil against your neighbor… Do not accuse anyone without legitimate cause, if he has not treated you wrongly. Do not envy a violent man, and do not choose to imitate any of his ways…

3:13 Blessed is the one who finds wisdom, and the one who obtains understanding.

4:24 Remove perverse speech from your mouth; keep devious talk far from your lips.

9:7 Whoever corrects a mocker is asking for insult; whoever reproves a wicked person receives abuse. Do not reprove a mocker or he will hate you; reprove a wise person and he will love you.

10:12 Hatred stirs up dissension, but love covers all transgressions.

10:19 When words abound, transgression is inevitable, but the one who restrains his words is wise.

11:2 When pride comes, then comes disgrace, but with humility comes wisdom.

12:11 The one who works his field will have plenty of food, but whoever chases daydreams lacks wisdom.

12:15 The way of a fool is right in his own opinion, but the one who listens to advice is wise.

12:16 A fool’s annoyance is known at once, but the prudent overlooks an insult.

13:11 Wealth gained quickly will dwindle away, but the one who gathers it little by little will become rich.

13:20 The one who associates with the wise grows wise, but a companion of fools suffers harm.

14:15 A naive person believes everything, but the shrewd person discerns his steps.

14:23 In all hard work there is profit, but merely talking about it only brings poverty.

14:29 The one who is slow to anger has great understanding, but the one who has a quick temper exalts folly

14:30 A tranquil spirit revives the body, but envy is rottenness to the bones.

15:1 A gentle response turns away anger, but a harsh word stirs up wrath

15:23 A person has joy in giving an appropriate answer, and a word at the right time – how good it is!

16:8 Better to have a little with righteousness than to have abundant income without justice.

16:18 Pride goes before destruction, and a haughty spirit before a fall.

17:1 Better is a dry crust of bread where there is quietness than a house full of feasting with strife.

17:28 Even a fool who remains silent is considered wise, and the one who holds his tongue is deemed discerning.

17:25 A foolish child is a grief to his father, and bitterness to the mother who bore him.

18:2 A fool takes no pleasure in understanding but only in disclosing what is on his mind.

18:9 The one who is slack in his work is a brother to one who destroys.

19:2 It is dangerous to have zeal without knowledge, and the one who acts hastily makes poor choices.

19:11 A person’s wisdom makes him slow to anger, and it is his glory to overlook an offense.

20:1 Wine is a mocker and strong drink is a brawler; whoever goes astray by them is not wise.

21:9 It is better to live on a corner of the housetop than in a house in company with a quarrelsome wife.

21:19 It is better to live in a desert land than with a quarrelsome and easily-provoked woman.
III. Some unwise sayings in the OT’s Proverbs:
1:7 Fearing the Lord is the beginning of moral knowledge. [No! Fear of death and desire to live are the beginning of moral knowledge! Recall from the Precepts of Ptah-hotep: “Let no one inspire men with fear; this is the will of Ptah.”]

2:1 My child, if you receive my words, and store up my commands within you… then you will understand how to fear the Lord, and you will discover knowledge about God. [Instead of trying to understand how “to fear the Lord”, try to understand by applying the scientific method!]

3:5 Trust in the Lord with all your heart, and do not rely on your own understanding. [It’s terrible to advise people not to rely on their own understanding (and to increase their understanding) and to “trust the Lord” rather than trust themselves!]

3:9 Honor the Lord from your wealth… [a ploy by clerics to increase their revenue stream!]

3:19 By wisdom the Lord laid the foundation of the earth; he established the heavens by understanding. By his knowledge the primordial sea was broken open, and the clouds drip down dew. [Riiiiight. And where did you say the data supporting that speculation were hidden?]

9:10 The beginning of wisdom is to fear the Lord, and acknowledging the Holy One is understanding. [Terrible, again!]

10.1 A wise child makes a father rejoice, but a foolish child is a grief to his mother. [That’s just male chauvinism.]

10:4 The one who is lazy becomes poor, but the one who works diligently becomes wealthy. [Would that it were so!]

13:24 The one who spares his rod hates his child… [That’s horrible!]

15:20 A wise child brings joy to his father, but a foolish person despises his mother. [More male chauvinism!]

16:12 Doing wickedness is an abomination to kings, because a throne is established in righteousness. [Riiiight. It’s another part of the Law Lie.]

16:15 In the light of the king’s face there is life, and his favor is like the clouds of the spring rain. [More of the same – an indication of “slave mentality”.]

16:31 Gray hair is like a crown of glory; it is attained in the path of righteousness. [Would that it were so!]

17:8 A bribe works like a charm for the one who offers it; in whatever he does he succeeds. [Maybe that’s a misprint!]

20:24 The steps of a person are ordained by the Lord – so how can anyone understand his own way? [What stupidity!]

20:30 Beatings and wounds cleanse away evil, and floggings cleanse the innermost being. [What evil!]

21:14 A gift given in secret subdues anger, and a bribe given secretly subdues strong wrath. [So, it wasn’t a misprint – it’s corruption!]

21:31 A horse is prepared for the day of battle, but the victory is from the Lord. [Another part of the God Lie.]

22:4 The reward for humility and fearing the Lord is riches and honor and life. [Show me the data!]

22:6 Train a child in the way that he should go, and when he is old he will not turn from it. [Part is correct (the part about the persistence of childhood indoctrination), but the premiss should be investigated. Does the author know how to “train a child in the way that he should go”? As Schopenhauer suggested, probably the best procedure is to train children not to be “trained” (!) and, instead, to encourage them to learn by themselves via experience.]

22:15 Folly is bound up in the heart of a child, but the rod of discipline will drive it far from him. [More hideousness!]
And so on it goes (through Proverbs 31), as readers can attest. If readers do so, I hope they’ll notice that the “Thirty Sayings” [Proverbs 22:17 – 24:22] are similar (and in some cases almost identical) to the Egyptian Instructions of Amenemope. In addition, there are many repetitions through the rest of Proverbs (repetitions that become quite boring), although the final set (Proverbs 31:10 – 31:31) is a refreshing change: they describe a “Wife of Noble Character”.

Finally, I'd ask readers to compare the above illustrations from “the wisdom literature” of the Ancient Sumerians, Egyptians, and Hebrews, and then, chose the one of the following two options that, in your opinion based on the evidence presented, seems most likely to have occurred:
1) That God (i.e., the first symmetry-breaking quantum fluctuation in the total void that led to the Big Bang) dropped in (about 14 billion years later) to provide advice to the authors of the Bible about Jewish cultural norms, or

2) That after living in groups for tens of thousands of years, people slowly developed knowledge about how to live together productively, passed their wisdom along to their offspring, recorded their thoughts when writing finally became available, and unsure about the origin of their customs, mistakenly concluded that their customs must have been decreed by their gods.
For readers who chose the first option, I hope that they’ll reread, especially, the quoted Sumerian proverbs – and I hope that all readers will join me in thanking the many scholars who worked so diligently and competently to decipher the ancient literature.

www.zenofzero.net

2009/02/27

The Law Lie - 2 - Justice


In the previous post in this series dealing with the God Lie, I tried to show some history that exposes the lie that morality is defined by the gods. I presented evidence suggesting that it wasn’t any god but nature (i.e., experience) that taught animals (including humans) how to evaluate morality, i.e., “the extent to which an action is right or wrong.” In turn, moral values (as with all values) must be evaluated with respect to some objective, and it was nature (not any god) that ordained that the prime purpose of all life is to continue, which is then the fundamental basis for the evaluation of morality. In the previous post I included examples demonstrating that, soon after writing was invented (approximately 5,000 years ago), humans recorded moral “rules” that experience had taught them – rules that later religious people [such as the authors and “redactors” of the first books of the Old Testament (OT), whom I’ve been identifying as Ezra and co-conspirators (Ezra & C-C)] claimed were given to them by their gods.

In this post I want to show some history exposing the lie that justice is the jurisdiction of the gods. As in the case of morality, no god had (or has) anything to do with justice; instead, nature (i.e., experience) taught and continues to teach social animals about both the meaning and the demand for justice. Justification for that claim is, however, somewhat more complicated than the similar claim about morality, in part because justice is (in some ways) a more complicated concept than morality. In particular, there are a number of different types of justice, which I’ll identify as natural justice (or nature’s justice), personal justice, and interpersonal justice. In turn, a complicated form of interpersonal justice is social justice, which is also commonly subdivided into different types, including retributive justice (in response to crimes), distributive justice (allocating resources, benefits, and responsibilities within societies), restorative justice (compensating for injustices), and procedural justice. Below, I’ll start with the meaning of the simplest type of justice (natural justice) and while proceeding through each type, I’ll try to show how “the god idea” corrupted and continues to corrupt their meanings.

1. Natural Justice
Natural justice is “just” the principle of causality: every outcome has its causes. Millions of years ago, animals learned the principle of causality by experience; those animals that didn’t learn (for example, that noises have causes) are now extinct. Humans, however, with their powers of imagination greater than animals and their unfortunate propensities to believe in the absence of evidence, identified incorrect causes of, for example, the wind (e.g., the wind god Woden), thunder and lightening (e.g., the gods Thor and Zeus), and volcanic eruptions (e.g., the Aztecs’ PopocatĂ©petl and the Hebrews’ Yahweh). Such misidentification of causes and labeling of unknowns with names of fictitious gods continue today, with theists (approximately 80% of all humans!) convinced that the cause of the universe and life is “Allah” or “Brahma” or “God”, all of which, in essence, are abbreviations for “I dunno”.

That unknown causes are labeled with otherwise nonsensical words would not, in itself, normally cause many problems. Major problems, however, did occur (and continue to occur), because some lying and/or mentally-challenged and/or mentally-ill people (commonly called clerics) claimed (and continue to claim) abilities to communicate with – and worse, speak for – the fictitious causes. This month, for example, Pope Benedict XVI (a fellow who claims to speak for his god and usually and appropriately wears an elaborate dunce cap) promoted, within his clerical hierarchy to Bishop of Linz, a fellow by the name of Father Wagner (although it would seem to be appropriate to investigate the claim that he is a “father”). Earlier, Wagner informed the world that the principal cause of hurricane Katrina (which hit New Orleans in 2005) wasn’t temperatures of the tropical Atlantic’s mixed layer in excess of 80°F and stimulating wind shears, but instead
…the death and destruction caused by Hurricane Katrina was “divine retribution” for excessive sexual permissiveness, including tolerance of homosexuality… He noted that Katrina destroyed not only nightclubs and brothels in New Orleans but also abortion clinics, adding “The conditions of immorality in this city are indescribable”.
Wagner’s “explanation” of the cause of Katrina, however, conflicts with the “explanation” offered by Mohammed Yousef Miaifi, that Katrina was
a wind of torment and evil that Allah has sent to this American empire.
It also conflicts with the “explanation” provided by Rabbi Ovadia Yosef:
America was punished because the Bush administration had pressured Israel into withdrawing settlers from Gaza.
Not incidentally, a similar flood of inane clerical pronouncements inundated humanity “explaining” the cause of the tsunami that hit Indonesia on 26 December 2004, leading many scientific humanists to hope for major, tectonic shifts in the crustal brains of such retards, who seem to have zero understanding of natural justice – or maybe they know, but they’re hooked on the perks that their pronouncements provide them.

Admittedly, though, it’s difficult to determine if such clerics are both fools and liars. They’re certainly fools, if for no other reason than to promote “explanations” that have zero evidence to support them. The liars are those clerics who concoct such “explanations”, knowing full well that they’re just pulling their “explanations” out of thin air. Similar indictments are appropriate for all clerics throughout history: various lying clerics concocted stories to “explain” how their gods created Earth and its life, why people die, why there are different languages, why floods and other natural disasters occur, etc., and later foolish clerics and religious people accepted (and still accept!) such “explanations” as the “true” causes. In addition, in some cases, later, lying clerics and politicians realize that the “explanations” are pure bunk, but they promote the stories anyway, for the profits accrued by selling such crazy stories.

Whenever any god is introduced in such stories (as in all “sacred scriptures” and “holy books”), the god violates natural justice, in that natural links between cause and effect are violated by something “supernatural” (i.e., something that doesn’t exist, since everything that exists is, perforce, natural). Accepting such violations of natural justice destroys our ability to understand natural processes: if some god could snap his fingers (or whatever) to form light, then we’d never understand physical process such as electromagnetic waves; if some god could snap his fingers (or whatever) to create life, then we’d never understand biological processes; if some god could snap his fingers (or whatever) to flood the earth, then we’d never understand meteorology or the hydrological cycle – and similarly for all alleged “miracles”, all of which violate the principle of causality. Stated differently, one of the firmest pieces of knowledge that humans have been able to determine is that no miracle (in the religious sense of the word ‘miracle’) has ever occurred. Therefore, all claims of religious miracles are either misunderstandings or lies, since all such claims violate natural justice.

2. Personal Justice
Appreciation for natural justice (that all effects have their causes) provided and continues to provide all animals (including humans) with a firm basis for the concept of personal justice. Again it’s nature (i.e., experience), not any god, that relentlessly teaches each and every one of us the meaning for personal justice throughout every day of our lives: when an animal seeks some food, when a baby reaches for a rattle, when an infant crawls to obtain a toy, when a child stands to reach an object, and so on, including when adults try to reach their goals, nature teaches us that when we’re able to influence an outcome, then we generally get what we deserve. In some cases, however, the “response time of the system” is slow (i.e., we don’t immediately get what we deserve) and some of us (e.g., smokers, alcoholics, drug addicts, gluttons, and religious people) are slow learners – at our own expense. Furthermore, the concept of personal justice (that we generally get what we deserve – and don’t get what we don’t deserve) is only a general rule, admitting many exceptions.

Sometimes, too, there’s confusion between natural and personal justice. For example, it isn’t personal justice that a baby is born with birth defects, a tornado destroys a person’s home, another person wins a lottery, and similar; instead, those are cases in natural justice (effects have their causes), including outcomes whose probabilities of occurrence were miniscule. Yet, even in such cases, some ingredients of personal justice can arise. Thus, the mother of the child born with deformed limbs would experience some personal justice if, during her pregnancy, she ingested thalidomide after she should have learned that it caused birth defects and its sale was banned worldwide. Similarly, if someone were injured by a tornado, there can be some personal justice if the person didn’t take appropriate precautions. And even a lottery winner experiences some personal justice, in that, although he bought into a game rigged against him, at least he tried to win.

The god idea, in contrast, destroyed (and continues to destroy) the concept of personal justice. Once people decided that some god controlled some outcome, then rather than try to influence the outcome directly (e.g., by seeking better hunting grounds, by domesticating animals, by planting crops, by building dams to stop floods, by storing grain for leaner times, etc.), then religious people chose to try to influence outcomes by propitiating the gods – undoubtedly with the urging of their priests who collected the offerings for the gods (and what the gods didn’t consume, the priests did). The resulting destruction of personal justice is illustrated by the unwise Sumerian proverb (from about 4500 years ago):
Fear of god creates good fortune. Lamentation absolves sin. Offerings extend life.
Similarly, from The Advice of the Akkadian Father to his Son, written in about 2200 BCE, there is the unfortunate recommendation:
Worship your god every day. Sacrifice and pious utterance are the proper accompaniment of incense. Have a freewill offering for your god, for this is proper toward a god. Prayer, supplication, and prostration offer him daily, then your prayer will be granted, and you will be in harmony with god.
And although it's sad to contemplate, consider that, today (4200 years later!), the majority of the people in the world apparently still “believe” that they can achieve favorable outcomes by praying to their gods, violating personal justice.

As a recent illustration of such idiocy, Roman Catholics learned this month that “indulgences” are back:
According to church teaching, even after sinners are absolved in the confessional and say their Our Fathers or Hail Marys as penance, they still face punishment after death, in Purgatory, before they can enter heaven. In exchange for certain prayers, devotions, or pilgrimages in special years, a Catholic can receive an indulgence, which reduces or erases that punishment instantly, with no formal ceremony or sacrament. You cannot buy one – the church outlawed the sale of indulgences in 1567 [Martin Luther’s denouncement of them ignited the Protestant Reformation 50 years earlier] – but charitable contributions [I wonder if donations only to Catholic charities are acceptable!], combined with other acts [and I wonder what kind of “other acts” the Catholic priests want!] can help you earn one.
I enjoyed the comment on the referenced story by William Manning of Boston, MA:
This can be our next great [financial] bubble! Bundle and securitize indulgences and let’s get them puppies on an exchange! How did Goldman Sachs ever let this one slip through their fingers?!
But in a way, such idiocy doesn’t thwart personal justice, because with their prayers, confessions, penances, indulgences, etc., Catholics (as well as all religious people) will, in the end, still generally get what they deserve.

3. Interpersonal & Social Justice
The concept of interpersonal justice (including social justice) is similar to the case for personal justice: our expectations and desires, based on personal experiences, that we should generally get what we deserve. The major complication of interpersonal justice, however, is that more than one person can influence the outcome; consequently, there’ll commonly be different opinions about who gets what's deserved.

In the simplest case of interpersonal justice, when only two people are involved, an ideal outcome was expressed well by an author whose name I’ve both forgotten and couldn't find using Google. Possibly the author was Eric Fromm. The author stated something close to: “Justice in interpersonal relationships is that you usually get out of them pretty much what you put in.”

As with personal justice, though, any “general rule” for interpersonal justice admits many exceptions. As an example, you may hold the opinion that a certain person should be a loyal friend, given all that you have done for him, but he might choose not to be your friend, assessing you to be a sycophant. As another example, one group obviously holds the opinion that those living in Gaza suffered a terrible injustice with last month’s bombings by Israel, whereas another group obviously holds the opinion that the inhabitants of Gaza got what they deserved for permitting Hamas to shoot rockets into Israel. As Ralf Waldo Emerson (1803–1882) said:
One man’s justice is another’s injustice…
Given that “One man’s [opinion about interpersonal or social] justice is another’s [opinion about] injustice”, the obvious question is: Whose opinion is “right”? In response to that question, nature (i.e., experience) taught all animals (including humans) another critical lesson – but it has taken humans a very long time to learn its full meaning. The lesson that animals know is “the law of the jungle”, i.e., “might makes right”. But another obvious question (at least for humans) is: What’s meant by ‘might’?

In the beginning for humanity, the ‘might’ in “might makes right” meant the same as it is does in the rest of the animal kingdom, i.e., “physical power”. For patriarchal societies, for fundamentalist branches of the Abrahamic religions (i.e., Judaism, Christianity, Islam, Mormonism, etc.), and for all bullies ‘might’ still unfortunately means “physical power”. Thus, just as the strongest stud rules his herd, in patriarchal societies the father rules his family (and the Bible and the Koran condone his ruling by force), and according to the con artists of the Abrahamic religions, God (or Allah), “the almighty”, is omnipotent (all powerful) and, therefore, always “right”.

As people assembled in larger groups (e.g., in the first Sumerian cities, populated more than 5,000 years ago), they discovered that, if they acted collectively, “there’s strength in numbers”, i.e., collectively they could have the most ‘might’. A major problem with such a choice, however, soon became apparent: almost invariably a group needs a leader, and although experience has shown that some leaders were benevolent [e.g., Urukagina (the leader of the world’s first known revolution, which occurred in the Sumerian city of Lagash in about 2350 BCE), Cyrus the Great, George Washington, the leaders of the Women’s Suffrage Movement, Mahatma (“great soul”) Gandhi, Martin Luther King…], yet in many other cases, the group leader became another malevolent tyrant (e.g., Sargon “the Great”, Alexander “the Great”, the “butcher emperor” Constantine, Muhammad, Hitler, Stalin, Mao…). In later posts I’ll provide some examples of groups seeking their opinions of social justice by relying on “might makes right” with ‘might’ derived from the truism that “there’s strength in numbers”; i.e., some examples of revolutions driven by “people power”. In this post, however, I want to focus on another approach that people found would sometimes work.

The first written record summarizing this alternative approach (showing that at least some humans had learned that ‘might’ needn’t mean either “physical strength” or “strength in numbers”) seems to be the Sumerian proverb (from more than 4,000 years ago):
Strength cannot keep pace with intelligence.
Of course, with every weapon invented (ever since bows and arrows replaced clubs) the inventors demonstrated that ‘might’ needn’t mean “physical strength”. But besides more lethal weapons, “mental weapons” can also be used to effectively overcome tyranny, satisfying the people’s desire that their opinion about social justice prevail. An illustration appears in the world’s oldest written story, the Sumerian’s Epic of Gilgamesh.

Now, for readers who haven’t read The Epic, a tremendous treat is available for you. You might want to delay reading the rest of this post until after you’ve read The Epic – although I admit that I’m worried that you won’t return, because The Epic is so engaging! The translation by Maureen Gallery Kovacs of the version of The Epic written (about 1,000 years before Ezra & C-C) by SĂ®n-leqi-unninni (or Sin-leqe-unnini or Shin-eqi-unninni, the world’s first-identified author and who was in the same league with Homer and Shakespeare) is available here, a summary by W.T.S. Thackara is here, and even I provide some background information and note a few highlights of The Epic here. If you want to start by watching some summary videos on YouTube, you might want to start here. If you plan to engage in a internet search for “The Epic of Gilgamesh”, then I might as well bid farewell, now!

For those still with me, what I want to do, next, is review a part of The Epic that deals with social justice. Then, I want to call readers attention to how horribly Ezra & C-C corrupted the concepts of justice compared with what was available to them in The Epic. As a summary, I’ll express my opinion that any student anywhere in the world polluted by the Abrahamic religions shouldn’t be awarded a high-school diploma without demonstrating substantial understanding of The Epic. If that were required, I expect that, within a few generations, the world would be rid of the damnable distortions of justice known as Judaism, Christianity, Islam, Mormonism, etc.

To begin, notice that at the start of the story about Gilgamesh, i.e., about “Gilga the hero” [apparently a story about the 27th century king Gilga of the Sumerian city of Uruk (spelled Erech in the OT and, in its time, probably the world’s largest city, with a population of about 50,000)], he’s depicted as a beast of a man, “a loose bull, nose up in open field”, claiming the right to be the first to sleep with any new bride, as well having sexual relations with other men’s wives and maybe also with other men’s boys. Feeling the injustices of the tyrant Gilga, the oppressed citizens of Uruk complain to the council of the gods, and consistent with the reality summarized by “as below, so above” (rather than the astrologers’ ridiculous “as above, so below”!), the council of the gods relay the people’s concern to Uruk’s city god, the sky god, god of heaven (and eventually the greatest of the Sumerian gods), Anu. In Kovacs’ translation, the council of gods confronts Anu with the accusation:
You have indeed brought into being a mighty wild bull, head raised! There is no rival who can raise a weapon against him. His fellows stand (at the alert), attentive to his (orders!), Gilgamesh does not leave a son to his father, day and night he arrogantly… Is he the shepherd of Uruk-Haven, is he their shepherd (?)... bold, eminent, knowing, and wise, Gilgamesh does not leave a girl to her mother!
The chief god Anu passes the buck to the goddess Aruru (“the almighty gentle mother goddess of the Earth and birth; she who first created humanity from clay”), leaving it to her to clean up the mess (again consistent with “as below, so above”!):
It was you, Aruru, who created mankind(?), now create a zikru to it/him. Let him be equal to his (Gilgamesh’s) stormy heart, let them be a match for each other so that Uruk may find peace!
In the above quotation, the meaning for the word zikru has been the subject of debate. The simplest interpretation is that the man created by Aruru (named Enkidu) was to be the people’s champion, but a case can be made (e.g., see here) that Enkidu was to be Gilga’s homosexual lover.

How the temple priestess Shamhat “tamed” the initially primitive man Enkidu with her womanly ways is another great part of the story (Tablets I & II). The story ends with (Tablet II, Column IV, line 50):
So Enkidu came then to know of Gilgamesh who harshly ruled and was not loved by those men whose girls he often played with all night long.

And before they entered through the gates of Uruk’s mighty walls, Enkidu was hailed as one who might be sent to rival any king who might treat gentle folk unfairly.
Subsequently, Enkidu and Gilgamesh became fast friends, the people had a story, and the story had a lesson: a lesson that social justice is just opinion, that whose opinion is right depends on might, but that ‘might’ needn’t mean “physical strength”, since “strength cannot keep pace with intelligence.” Thus, with the alleged help of the gods, the people used their intelligence to find a way to overcome the strength of Gilga, distracting him from his wanton ways by providing him with a worthy friend who would be his companion in brave new adventures.

If everyone had learned the lesson that “strength cannot keep pace with intelligence”, we would probably now have a more-peaceful world. History shows, however, that people didn’t learn. A major problem seems to be that, although the Sumerian proverb that “strength cannot keep pace with intelligence” may be correct, it neglects to address that the ‘strength’ (or ‘might’) in “might makes right” had a huge head start – after ruling in the rest of the animal kingdom for millions of years. Consequently, although in the long run (measured in tens of thousands of years!) intelligence may outpace strength, yet during the past 4,000 years, the might of the Akkadians, Amorites, Hittites, Kassites, Assyrians, Persians, Greeks, Romans, Huns, Christians, Muslims, Imperialists, Fascists, Communists, etc. was based not on intelligence but on armaments. And still today, “smart bombs” seem to vastly outnumber “smart people”.

To help people smarten-up, to help intelligence finally catch-up with strength, to test the wisdom in the Sumerian proverb “strength cannot keep pace with intelligence”, to achieve greater peace not just for Uruk but the world, it seems that we must be wiser than our ancestors. The quotations above suggest that peace in Uruk couldn’t be achieved without justice. That same idea is applicable today:
In awarding the Nobel Peace Prize to the International Labour Organization (ILO) in 1969, the Nobel Committee referred to the motto enshrined in the foundations of the ILO’s original building in Geneva, “Si vis pacem, cole justitiam.” [If you desire peace, cultivate justice.] As another example, if the documentary about the Los Angeles riots associated with the Rodney King trial is correct, then apparently the rioters chanted the corollary: “No justice; no peace.”
But since social justice is just opinion, peace would seem to require uniformity in opinion, which is essentially impossible to achieve. Instead, as I’ve argued elsewhere, the best we can achieve is apparently as described by the Ancient Greek philosopher Heraclitus (c.540 – c.480 BCE): “an attunement of opposite tensions, like that of the bow and the lyre.” In turn, if a melodious attunement of opposite tensions is to be achieved, then most important is that opinions be based on evidence (i.e., on experience, i.e., by applying the scientific method) rather than on speculations (the essence of all organized religions).

Almost 5,000 years ago, according to The Epic, the ancient Sumerians living in Uruk had evidence to support their opinion about Gilga’s injustices. Then, however (so the myth informs us), the people (consistent with their superstitions) petitioned the gods with grievances, gods who the people assumed were in charge of justice. Of course, that’s the story in the myth – written by priests! In reality, if anything similar to the story actually occurred, then more likely is that the temple priestess, Shamhat, knew that Gilga was a beast, heard that a “wild man” was living in the woods, and by herself (or with the help of friends), she set out to tame the wild man, to become the people’s challenger of Gilga. Today, as incredible as it may seem, not only do religious Jews, Christians, Muslims, Mormons, etc. still consider their (non-existent) gods to be “just”, they accept myths about their fictitious gods as evidence!

That religious people today imagine their gods to be “just” is evident in their “holy books”. We’re told in the “holy Bible”, for example, that the first symmetry-breaking quantum fluctuation in a total void that led to the Big Bang (i.e., “God”) popped in to tell Isaiah and Jeremiah:
“For I, the LORD, love justice; I hate robbery and iniquity.” (Isaiah 61, 8)

“… I am the LORD, who exercises kindness, justice, and righteousness on earth, for in these I delight…” (Jeremiah 9, 24)
Followers of the other Abrahamic religions consider the above quotes to be “sacred scripture”, and in their Koran, Muslims have in addition:
Allah bears witness that there is no god but He, and (so do) the angels and those possessed of knowledge, maintaining His creation with justice… (Sura 3, 18)
Strangely enough, though (at least I hope it seems strange to followers of Abrahamic religions), the clerics of the gods of Ancient Mesopotamia claimed essentially the same. Thus, Utu (Sumerian) or Shamash (Akkadian) was described as both the Sun god and “the god of justice”. Later, in Babylon, Shamash’s two sons, Misharu and Kittu were the gods of justice and truth, respectively. Still later in Babylon, when Marduk (originally son of the Sun god Shamash) was promoted to “chief god”, one of his fifty (!) names was Shazu, who “oversees justice and subdues rebellion, he has rooted out malice, wherever he goes the wrong and the right stand separate.” Given those identifications (one to two thousand years before Moses, Isaiah, Jeremiah, et al. claimed that theirs was the god of justice!), one would hope that “modern” Jews, Christians, Muslims, and Mormons would become at least a little suspicious that they’ve been had – by clerics promoting a pack of lies.

In reality, interpersonal and social justice aren’t provided or promoted by any god but, as with morality, arise from behaviors that experience demonstrated (and chose by “natural selection”) to be beneficial for the survival of members of the social group. Readers interested in examining support for that claim might want to start at the blog of the Living Links Center at the Yerkes National Primate Research Center of Emory University. For animals such as mice, monkeys, and canines, failure to achieve perceived justice commonly results in fights, consistent with “might makes right”.

For humans, with social interactions commonly more complicated than among other animals and with desires of the majority of humans to suppress the law of the jungle, assessing and achieving social justice is commonly more difficult. During tens of thousands of years, controversies among humans were resolved by the leaders of tribes, councils of elders, and similar. Clerics of the Abrahamic religions, however, claim that their god oversees such deliberations in procedural justice and promotes distributive and retributive justice. For example, we find in the Bible that the first symmetry-breaking quantum fluctuation in a total void admonished:
Do not spread false reports. Do not help a wicked man by being a malicious witness. Do not follow the crowd in doing wrong. When you give testimony in a lawsuit, do not pervert justice by siding with the crowd… (Exodus 23, 1–2)

Do not pervert justice; do not show partiality to the poor or favoritism to the great, but judge your neighbor fairly. (Leviticus 19, 15)

Do not accept a bribe, for a bribe blinds the eyes of the wise and twists the words of the righteous. (Deuteronomy 16, 19)

Do not deprive the alien or the fatherless of justice, or take the cloak of the widow as a pledge. (Deuteronomy 24, 17)
Similarly, we find in the Koran
Surely Allah enjoins the doing of justice and the doing of good (to others)… (Sura 16, 90)
But such ideas obviously weren’t conceived by clerics of the Abrahamic god; instead, the ideas were copied from thousands of years earlier, developed in both Mesopotamia and Egypt. Some examples from Mesopotamia can been seen in Sumerian proverbs, including
The expenses of those who neglect justice are numerous.

He who despises a just decision, who loves wicked decisions, is an abomination.

Thanks to the word of his personal god, the fate of the man who speaks just words is favorable, and he is with him throughout the day.
Many more examples are given in the book (partially available at Google Books) by Elisabeth Meier Tetlow and entitled Women, Crime, and Punishment in Ancient Law and Society, Vol. 1, the Ancient Near East (Continuum Int. Publ. Grp, 2004), including the following.
Royal Sumerian lawgivers expressed their goals of justice and protection of the poor and oppressed, including women, especially vulnerable women such as widows without children. They believed that these goals could be achieved through written laws, impartial courts, and a workable system for the administration of justice. The city-states of Sumer developed judicial systems early in the third millennium. First the assemblies of the city-states functioned as courts and later there were panels of judges. Trials were conducted in a formal manner: facts were gathered in evidence, the arguments of both sides were heard, guilt was deliberated by the assembly, and in the case of conviction, sentence was handed down. Defendants had the right to appeal, generally to their ruler or to the king of the dominant city-state in the area. Women were treated the same as men under the laws and in the courts of Sumer…

The Early Dynastic king Ur-Nanshe [or Ur-Nina, 24th Century BCE] of Lagash built a temple and named it for the god of justice. Four centuries later, king Gudea of Lagash wrote that justice came from the gods and in practice justice meant protecting widows, orphans, and the poor from the rich and powerful. King Lipit-Ishtar of Isin proudly claimed that he establish justice in Sumer and Akkad by implementing fair judicial procedure and by erecting a stele of his laws.

[There are] few extant sources of laws… one exception was Uru-inimgina, king of Lagash in the late twenty-fourth century BCE. Only a few of his laws are known… describe the abuse of power by the aristocracy and priests… who oppressed the poor and the powerless. King Uru-inimgina stated his intent to protect the vulnerable, especially poor mothers and widows, from further oppression… [He] forbade his officials and priests to enter and steal from the gardens and orchards of women. Upper-class men and women were forbidden to steal fish from the ponds of the commoners…

[Gudea, ruler of Lagash from ca. 2144–2124] paid attention to the justice of Nance [or Nanshe, daughter of Enki and who “judged the wicked and fought for social justice”] and Nin-jirsu [the god of war]. He provided protection for the orphan against the rich, and provided protection for the widow against the powerful… A day of justice dawned for him. He set his foot on the neck of evil ones and malcontents…

The extant text includes a prologue and thirty-four laws… The prologue described the ways in which king Ur-Nammu [Third Dynasty of Ur: 2112–2004] acted to establish justice in the land of Sumer and banish crime, violence, and strife. The stated purpose of the laws was to establish justice by correcting abuses prevalent at the time and by mandating the protection of widows, orphans, and poor persons against oppression by the wealthy and powerful…

The last non-Amorite dynasty of ancient Sumer was the first dynasty of Isin, of which Lipit-Ishtar was the fifth king. He promulgated his collection of laws about 1930 BCE. A prologue, an epilogue, and thirty-eight laws are wholly or partially legible. In the prologue, Lipit-Ishtar stated that he was chosen king by the gods “to establish justice in the land, to eliminate cries for justice, to eradicate enmity and armed violence, to bring well-being to the lands of Sumer and Akkad.”… In the epilogue, the king proclaimed his accomplishments: the establishment of “fair judicial procedure”; the eradication of enmity and violence, weeping, and lamentation; and the establishment of right and truth.
Another example from Mesopotamia (during the first Babylonian period) is contained in The Great Hymn to Shamash:
You [Shamash] give the unscrupulous judge experience of fetters [i.e., throw the bum in jail!]. Him who accepts a present [i.e., a bribe] and yet lets justice miscarry, you make bear his punishment. As for him who declines a present but nevertheless takes the part of the weak… it is pleasing to Shamash, and he will prolong his life…
In Ancient Egypt, meanwhile, the first written reference to social justice appears to be from the “wise man” Ptah Hotep, from the 24th century BCE, who wrote:
As a leader, if you have to decide on the conduct of a great number of people, seek the most perfect manner of doing this so that your own conduct may be without reproach. Justice is great, invariable, and assured; it has not been disturbed since the age of Ptah [the creator god – although other translations use, here, the name of the god Osiris; in that case, the quotation would be consistent with the suggestion that there was an early Egyptian ruler named Osiris, who was later worshiped]…
Another example from Ancient Egypt containing ideas about social justice is from The Teachings for Merikare, written sometime between 2135-2040 BCE by a father to his son, Merikare, who apparently was to be the successor of the father’s social position:
Be skillful in speech, that you may be strong… words are braver than all fighting… Do justice, that you may live long upon earth. Calm the weeper, do not oppress the widow, do not oust a man from his father’s property… Beware of punishing wrongfully; do not kill…
It seems clear that such ideas from Ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia were copied into the OT, which contains:
Cursed is the one who moves his neighbor’s boundary marker…Cursed is the one who perverts justice for the resident foreigner, the orphan, and the widow. (Deuteronomy 27, 17 & 19)

Rob not the poor, because he is poor; neither oppress the afflicted in the gate. (Proverbs 22, 20-21)

Remove not the ancient landmark. (Proverbs 22, 22)
In fact, statements almost identical to the above are included in The Saying of Amenemope (an Egyptian), recorded in the 11th Century BCE:
Beware of robbing a wretch or attacking a cripple.

Do not move the markers on the border of the fields.
So, the clerics who wrote the OT (and the New Testament or NT, the Koran, the Book of Mormon, etc.) clearly didn’t develop new concepts either of a “god of justice” or details about social justice. Instead, they simply repackaged such ideas described thousands of years earlier by Egyptians and Mesopotamians, who in turn were summarizing ideas about social justice that people had developed tens of thousands of years earlier – and some of these ideas about justice were known by social animals such as monkeys millions of years ago! Furthermore, and more significantly, the Abrahamic clerics’ repackaged “god of justice” isn’t just.

Justifying that last statement (i.e., showing that the god of the principal “holy books” of western culture isn’t just) is a major undertaking. Elsewhere, 30 chapters of my online book describe some of the “sick policies” promoted in the Bible, the Koran, and the Book of Mormon, and approximately half of those “sick policies” are examples of natural, personal, and interpersonal (including social) injustices. Here, I certainly don’t want to go through those examples again. Instead, I’ll review only a single example, taken from the first few pages of the Bible (dealing with the myth about Adam and Eve), an example that’s “revered” by all religious Jews, Christians, Muslims, and Mormons – and thereby, they “revere” an unjust god.

For followers of Orthodox Judaism (who fortunately sum to only a small percentage of all Jewish people), the Adam and Eve myth is straightforward. Adam and Eve were told not to eat the fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil, they disobeyed God’s order, and as a result, they – and all their descendants (including us!) – were punished: men would need to work for a living, women would need not only to bear the pains of childbirth but also to submit to their husbands as their masters, and all humans would die. But that judgment (allegedly by God, but in reality, merely the machinations of some misogynous myth makers) was unjust. Thus, Adam and Eve did nothing wrong (and therefore, shouldn’t have been punished at all): the myth makers had their god preclude Adam and Eve from knowing the difference between right and wrong; therefore, they couldn’t know that it was “good” to obey God and “evil” to disobey him. Further, even if Adam and Eve had done something wrong (but they didn’t – because they couldn’t!), it would be unjust to punish subsequent humans for the alleged crime of our ancestors: we’re innocent; we have a perfect alibi; we weren’t there!

Christian (and Mormon) clerics compound the injustices in the myth about Adam and Eve. According to them (following the teachings of the insane “Saint” Paul), God had mercy on subsequent humans (whom he unjustly condemned to death!) and decided to “atone” for the (non-) sin of Adam and Eve by “sacrificing” his “only begotten son”, Jesus, on the cross – and if people would just believe that Paul wasn't crazy (plus pay the clerics for running their con game), then they're promised (for what it's worth!) that they'll be rewarded not with dunce caps but with eternal life in paradise. But Paul's (crazy) speculation just compounded God’s injustice, since thereby, he allegedly killed someone claimed to be the epitome of innocence (Jesus) to atone for the sins of the alleged guilty. Imagine the havoc that such a precedent would wreck on procedural justice today. What would the crazy Christian and Mormon clerics have us do: kill innocent babies in their cribs to “atone” for the crimes of murderers on death row?!

Muslims adopt a different twist on the same myth. Earlier in the biblical myth (Genesis 2, 18–20) God has Adam name all the animals:
The Lord God said, “It is not good for the man to be alone. I will provide a partner for him.” So God formed out of the ground all the wild animal of the field and every bird of the air. He brought them to the man to see what he would name them, and whatever the man called each living creature, that was its name. So the man named all the animals, the birds of the air, and the living creatures of the field…
What language Adam used to name the animals isn’t mentioned – but then, whatever language he used, all he needed to do was issue a series of distinct grunts and the animals would have “names”!

But upon hearing the above story, Muhammad (or subsequent Muslim clerics who wrote the Koran) spun the story differently; as a result, in the Koran it appears as follows (Sura 2, 31–39).
And He [God or Allah] taught Adam all the names [of the animals, rather than let Adam name them], then presented them to the angels; then He said: Tell me the names of those [animals] if you are right. They said: “Glory be to Thee! we have no knowledge but that which Thou hast taught us; surely Thou art the Knowing, the Wise.” [Allah’s “claim to fame” is that he knows the (arbitrary) names of animals? What silliness!]

He said: “O Adam! inform them of their names.” Then when he [Adam] had informed them of their names, He said: “Did I not say to you that I surely know what is ghaib [unseen and unknown] in the heavens and the earth and (that) I know what you manifest and what you hide?” [The evidence that Allah is omniscient consists of his demonstrating that he knows the names of the animals? Somebody’s gotta be kidding!]

And when We [the Royal ‘We’] said to the angels “Make obeisance to Adam” they did obeisance, but Iblis [Satan] (did it not). He refused and he was proud, and he was one of the unbelievers. [Good for Satan! Why on Earth (or anywhere else) should anyone “show obeisance” to someone who happens to know the names of animals?! To this day I hope that no one would “show obeisance” to someone who memorized some jargon!]

And We said: “O Adam! Dwell you and your wife in the garden and eat from it a plenteous (food) wherever you wish and do not approach this tree, for then you will be of the unjust.” [It’s “unjust” not to do what you’re told? Suppose that (as in the Koran) Allah told you to beat your wife if she doesn't obey you and to kill people if they don't believe in your fairy tales?!]

But the Shaitan [the Devil, same as Iblis] made them both fall from it, and caused them to depart from that (state) in which they were; and We said: “Get forth, some of you being the enemies of others, and there is for you in the earth an abode and a provision for a time.” [Not a very profound pronouncement!]

Then Adam received (some) words from his Lord, so He [Allah] turned to him mercifully; surely He is Oft-returning (to mercy), the Merciful. We said: “Go forth from this (state) all; so surely there will come to you a guidance from Me, then whoever follows My guidance, no fear shall come upon them, nor shall they grieve. And (as to) those who disbelieve in and reject My communications, they are the inmates of the fire, in it they shall abide.”
And if that isn’t unjust (and unmerciful!), then I don’t know what is. In essence, the Koran’s claim is that, unless you believe in its myths, then you’ll burn in Hell for eternity. In response, my considered opinion (delivered with all respect that’s due to anyone who advocates such unmerciful injustice - and idiocy) is: “Blow it out your ear!”

Now, the above was just a single illustration of injustices promoted by clerics of the Abrahamic religions; it dealt with only the first myth in their “holy books”; the reader might then agree that space limitations on this post preclude my showing hundreds (?) of other examples. Instead, I’ll relay that the sick policies in the NT, alone, drove me to concoct the following limericks, dealing with:

Natural Justice

As for miracles done (so it’s said!)
Like feed thousands from two loaves of bread…
Well – such stuff they relate
Lead sane people to state:
“Nature’s justice got dumped on its head!”

If he really possessed what it takes,
If his magic surpassed that of snakes,
Then to start: fix the Earth –
Since tectonics give birth
To volcanoes, tsunamis, and quakes!

Personal Justice

Although Jesus said he was the way
(And the truth and the light) I just say:
If words still have meaning
The way that I’m leaning:
The worst thing in the world is to pray!

As for healings it’s claimed that he did
Cure the sick and the odd invalid,
But to say that the blame
Fell on sins of the lame
Is a crime that a god should forbid!

Interpersonal Justice

Although Christ, without jest, clearly told
All the rich no more money to hold;
He said: “Just buy friends,
“Thereby, make amends” –
But what “friends” can you buy with mere gold?!

Though Jesus told people: “Be meek;
Let villains slap cheek after cheek.”
I find that I stumble:
Should they be called humble
When heaven’s the goal that they seek?

Distributive Justice

Yes, Jesus said give to the needy,
To all who just whimper “please feed me”;
Those who don’t – go to hell
Those who do – fare quite well –
Cause heaven is home for the greedy!

Although Jesus kept blessing the losers
(All the needy, the weepers, and users),
I know bloody well
That it’s evil as hell
To say naught but “alas” for producers!

Retributive Justice

Although Jesus said those, all alone,
Without sin were to cast the first stone;
His reasoning’s sad:
To not punish bad
Is the way still more evil is sown!

Although Jesus said we should abstain,
Yet I think we should firmly explain:
No matter how long,
To torture is wrong,
To judge humans you must be humane!

Procedural Justice

Although Paul said that Christ was divine,
The atonement HE made I decline:
Since I wasn’t there
I really don’t care –
The original sin wasn’t mine!

Although Jesus did brazenly state
That a heaven or hell we would rate,
What he said was just rot,
For true justice is not
To have tyrants decide on our fate!

Social Justice

Although Christ said that gold makes you sad,
And the perfect should yield all they had,
It’s not clear to me
That he ever did see:
Spreading evil to others is bad!

Although Jesus preached pacifist lore
(That to those who would take you give more),
He was no “Prince of Peace”,
Since it never would cease:
Because yielding to tyrants breeds war!

General Justice

Although Christ didn’t see his own premiss
It’s imperative to see what it is:
If people are served
Beyond what’s deserved,
It corrupts the essence of ‘justice’!

Although Jesus caught lawyers' attentions,
About justice he never once mentions:
True justice is not
Some god’s juggernaut
But attunement of opposite tensions!

Although Christ with God’s justice was awed,
There is something that all can applaud:
A new time has come,
Without Christendom,
When the people own justice – not God!

If Jesus came back here today,
I’d tell him to take it away:
His heaven and hell,
His justice as well,
They all went their Darwinian way.

Here, instead of my providing additional examples of God’s (or Jesus’s or Allah’s) injustices that appear throughout the “sacred scriptures” of the Abrahamic religions, it might be of interest to readers to consider additional examples of how their clerics corrupted the concepts of justice that appeared in The Epic of Gilgamesh. I’ll list the following “teasers”.

Corruption of natural justice
In The Epic, it clearly wasn’t a worldwide “supernatural” flood, which is hydrologically impossible; instead, it was a river-valley flood, undoubtedly with a natural cause.

Corruption of personal justice
In The Epic, as one example of personal justice (i.e., that you generally get what you deserve), Gilga lost the opportunity for eternal life not because of any god’s involvement but because of Gilga’s carelessness: when he was bathing in a spring of cool water (Tablet XI), “a snake smelled the fragrance of the plant [“by which a man can attain his survival”], silently came up, and carried off the plant – and while going back, the snake sloughed off its casing [as a sign of gaining eternal life].”

A more significant example of the corruption of personal justice by the authors of the OT can be seen by comparing the personal satisfaction that Gilga felt for his own accomplishments (e.g., building the walls of Uruk) versus the “success” obtained via the ill-begotten gains of Abraham (from pimping his wife and blackmailing her clients), of Jacob (from cheating his brother Esau out of his inheritance), of Joseph (from his monopoly of Egyptian grain), and of Moses (from his murdering rampages).

Corruption of interpersonal justice
Consistent with the general rule of interpersonal justice mentioned earlier (that you generally get out of relationships pretty much what you put in), the best outcome for two people is that they become fast friends. In The Epic, friendship between Gilgamesh and Enkidu is a central theme of the entire story. In the OT, in contrast (as far as I recall – and for that matter, as far as I recall, also in the NT, the Koran, and the Book of Mormon), the theme of friendship is never developed (save for the imagined friendship between people and their god): not friendship between two men or two women (save for the possibly homosexual relationship between King David and Jonathan) and not even friendship between husband and wife (save possibly between Jacob and his second wife Rachel).

Instead of describing such “healthy relationships” and developing the theme of interpersonal justice, the authors of the OT describe multiple cases of interpersonal injustices, not only between men and women (replacing it with a master-slave relationship) but even between brothers and other relatives. It’s as if the authors of the OT focused on the lines in The Epic in which Utnapishtim (Noah) states:
For how long do we build a household?
For how long do we seal a document!
For how long do brothers share the inheritance?
For how long is there to be jealousy in the land(?)!
Thus, the OT authors describe animosities between brothers (e.g., Jacob stealing Esau’s inheritance, the jealous brothers of Joseph selling him into slavery, and Aaron’s complaining to God about Moses) and between other male relatives (e.g., Noah’s condemning his grandson to slavery, Isaac’s brother-in-law Laban tricking Jacob and Jacob's getting even, and Joseph getting even with his brothers for selling him into slavery).

In the NT, not only is the central human emotion of friendship similarly absent (e.g., among the disciples), some obvious rivalries develop among the disciples (e.g., “the one He loved most” and of course the rivalry between Peter and Paul). Also, all the disciples abandon Jesus before his trial, simultaneously abandoning any hint of interpersonal justice. Again, the only exception seems to be the imagined friendship between people and their god. And I admit that I feel sorry for such people, for example those who claim (e.g., on bumper stickers): “Jesus loves me.” The poor souls seem to take comfort in imagining that at least someone loves them. In reality, however, all they get from their investment in the relationship is a stimulated imagination – while the clerics rake in their ill-gotten gains.

Corruption of Social Justice
In The Epic, the original social injustices perpetrated by Gilga were remedied; in the Bible, social injustice is rampant. In The Epic, for example, even the chief god complained about the injustice of killing everyone in the flood:
How, how could you bring about a flood without consideration? Charge the violation to the violator, charge the offense to the offender, but be compassionate lest (mankind) be cut off. Be patient lest they be killed.
In the OT, in contrast, the clerical authors have God show zero compassion for all the innocent babies, bees, and bunny rabbits allegedly killed in the flood.

Another example of corruption of social justice can be seen in implications from corruption of personal justice. Thus, in The Epic, Gilga’s achievements (e.g., building the walls of Uruk) benefited the city’s inhabitants; yet, in the Bible (both in the OT and NT), there’s essentially zero praise or reward for producers; instead, those who prosper are the liars and the devious (such as Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, et al.) and those praised are the losers (e.g., “the meek shall inherit the Earth”). For me, the distributive social injustices described in the Bible (failing to reward producers and instead praising nonproducers – such as all clerics!) are so pervasive that they make the entire book reek of slavery and communism.

As my final example of social justice in The Epic corrupted into injustices in the OT, the reader is invited to consider the following quotation from pp. 44–45 of the old book An Old Babylonian Version of The Gilgamesh Epic by Anonymous, edited by Morris Jastrow (1861–1921) and obviously written soon after another tablet (“the Pennsylvania tablet”) of The Epic had been found during the 19th Century:
We now obtain, thanks to the new section revealed by the Pennsylvania tablet, a further analogy with the story of Adam and Eve, but with this striking difference, that whereas in the Babylonian tale the woman is the medium leading man to the higher life, in the Biblical story the woman is the tempter who brings misfortune to man.

This contrast is, however, not inherent in the Biblical story, but due to the point of view of the Biblical writer, who is somewhat pessimistically inclined and looks upon primitive life (when man went naked and lived in a garden, eating of fruits that grew of themselves) as the blessed life in contrast to advanced culture, which leads to agriculture and necessitates hard work as the means of securing one’s substance. Hence the woman through whom Adam eats of the tree of knowledge and becomes conscious of being naked is looked upon as an evil tempter, entailing the loss of the primeval life of bliss in a gorgeous Paradise.

The Babylonian point of view is optimistic. The change to civilized life – involving the wearing of clothes and the eating of food that is cultivated (bread and wine) is looked upon as an advance. Hence the woman is viewed as the medium of raising man to a higher level.

The feature common to the Biblical and Babylonian tales is the attachment of a lesson to early folk-tales. The story of Adam and Eve, as the story of Enkidu and the woman, is told with a purpose. Starting with early traditions of men’s primitive life on earth, that may have arisen independently, Hebrew and Babylonian writers diverged, each group going its own way, each reflecting the particular point of view from which the evolution of human society was viewed.

Leaving the analogy between the Biblical and Babylonian tales aside, the main point of value for us in the Babylonian story of Enkidu and the woman is the proof furnished by the analysis, made possible through the Pennsylvania tablet, that the tale can be separated from its subsequent connection with Gilgamesh. We can continue this process of separation in the fourth column [of the tablet], where the woman instructs Enkidu in the further duty of living his life with the woman decreed for him, to raise a family, to engage in work, to build cities and to gather resources. All this is looked upon in the same optimistic spirit as marking progress, whereas the Biblical writer, consistent with his point of view, looks upon work as a curse, and makes Cain, the murderer, also the founder of cities. The step to the higher forms of life is not an advance according to the J document [i.e., the part of the Pentateuch authored by “J”].

It is interesting to note that even the phrase the “cursed ground” occurs in both the Babylonian and Biblical tales; but whereas in the latter (Gen. 3, 17) it is because of the hard work entailed in raising the products of the earth that the ground is cursed, in the former (lines 62–63) it is the place in which Enkidu lives before he advances to the dignity of human life that is “cursed,” and which he is asked to leave. Adam is expelled from Paradise as a punishment, whereas Enkidu is implored to leave it as a necessary step towards progress to a higher form of existence.
Subsequently, Christian, Muslim, and Mormon clerics adopted the same injustices, not only against women but also against all people who seek progress toward a more civilized life. The crazy clerics promote the weird idea that the best way forward is to go backward! Thus, they assume (not only without any evidence to support their assumption but also in conflict with all evidence supporting the concept of evolution) that humanity started in paradise, and they speculate (again with zero scientific support for their speculation) that not only was “the fall of man” caused by women but also that, if only humanity will obey the clerics, then paradise will once more be realized – a glorious “end time” when their god (and they!) will rule.

In reality, what the clerics of the Abrahamic religions support is not evolution but devolution (as in ‘degeneration’ or ‘retrogression’) as well as corruption:
• Corruption of natural justice (claiming that their “supernatural” god can perform “miracles”, modifying natural links between causes and effects),

• Corruption of personal justice (claiming that invoking their god will give the petitioner not what’s deserved but what’s desired), and

• Corruption of interpersonal and social justice (claiming that their opinions – that women are second class citizens, that abortions, homosexuality, masturbation, etc., are “abominations before the Lord”, that rulers rule “by the grace of God”, and all the other ingredients of the damnable God Lie – are not just their opinions but “God’s will”).
For me, it brings to mind what Socrates said: “There is only one good, knowledge, and one evil, ignorance.” I would have preferred if he had said something similar to: “There is only one good, willingness to learn, and one evil, refusal.” But in either case, the same conclusion seems clear: the ignorance of clerics – in particular, their refusal to learn basic science – is evil.

As a result, as I’ve argued elsewhere: since social justice is just opinion, the worst of the clerics’ evil is that a harmonious “attunement of opposite tensions” can’t be achieved (and without it, peace won’t be achieved) until opinions are based on scientific evidence rather than religious speculations. I’d therefore argue not “to achieve peace, cultivate justice”, but to achieve peace, plow all religious weeds under (there to decompose) and in their place, plant science. In turn, that means rejecting all “knowledge” claimed to be obtained by “revelation” and replacing it with knowledge obtained by the scientific method: rely on data not dogma!

www.zenofzero.net